480sparky

It is legal to remove the 'guts' of one HID type, and replace it with another?

IE; If I had a fixture that is 250w HPS, is it 'legal' to remove the ballast, ignitor & capacitor, and replace it with the workings of a 250 MH?

__________________
This message is hidden because Forgery, JackBoot, LawnGuyLandSparky, milehiwire and user 5941 are on your ignore list.

paul d.

would that change the UL approval rating???

480sparky

Don't know why it would...

I recently installed 3 250w HPS at a school. One turned out to be a 250w MH, box was mislabeled. Didn't catch it until I installed the bulb. Housings, lens, etc. were identical.

Only other difference was the sticker on the inside identifying it as a MH.

__________________
This message is hidden because Forgery, JackBoot, LawnGuyLandSparky, milehiwire and user 5941 are on your ignore list.

frenchelectrican

Yes it can be done and I done that more than few time with HID luminaire espcally if reballast it.

If the manufacter did ran the number on the luminaire it should be match up however it pretty common to use the same housing for diffrent type of ballast { HPS, PSMH, MH , CFL , SCFL }

But I do not know what it will affect the UL label unless it got second one in there somewhere.

Merci,Marc

__________________
Pas de problème,il marche n'est-ce pas?"(No problem, it works doesn't it?)

reddog

Each hid fixture has a T- RATING , which are determined in what areas you can used the fixture in safely because of the haszard present. The fixtures i am referring to are the ones used in class1, 2 ,or 3 areas. Not sure about non classified fixtures.

Bob Badger

IMO a clear 110.3(B) violation.

Would it be unsafe? I doubt it but who am I to say?

MDShunk

After a while, you'll notice a trend that many, many manufacturers use the same exterior housing of a certain fixture for a great many "guts" inside.

I recently changed out (4) huge 400-watt HPS fixtures and changed them into 1000W MH fixtures. I had no problem doing this, since I recognized the fixture housing as also being the housing for 1000W fixtures at another customer's location. It even had a variety of tapped holes inside for the larger 1000W ballast.

Sometimes, I believe, you can overthink stuff. I'm also certain it's a 110.3(B) violation, but it won't stop me from doing it anyhow if I belive the fixture housing was meant at the factory to accomodate some other type or size of ballast.

__________________

nolabama

Merry Christmas Marc.

__________________
“Dammit, Smithers, this isn’t rocket science, it’s brain surgery!”

DipsyDoodleDandy

Firstly, make sure theres nothing flammable near because the lawyers will find a way to make it your fault.

Bob Badger

That is really the only reason I would not do it, besides we make money selling fixtures.

Heck sometimes it is more economical to replace a fixture then it is to repair them. You can sometimes get a small low wattage wall pack with lamp for less them a lamp and ballast kit.

cschmid

I find that to more offten true then not..

John Valdes

Oops

__________________
If your not getting old, you're dead.
Tom Petty

Peter D

There is one danger to be aware of when doing this, and that is the optics of the reflector. The reflector must be designed for the lamp, otherwise, too much energy can be reflected back into the arc tube thereby shortening the life of the lamp.

frenchelectrican

I have see that in both Americian and European verison if wrong reflector used it can do more damage than it worth plus with HPS it kinda senstive but for MH good chance it will blow the arc tube.

Merci,Marc

__________________
Pas de problème,il marche n'est-ce pas?"(No problem, it works doesn't it?)