Electrician Talk banner

Dewalt Impact Driver

22K views 58 replies 24 participants last post by  TOOL_5150  
#1 ·
What's the difference between them all 1/2, 1/4, Hex, Heavy Duty, XPS.

My god why so many versions?!

Which one do I want to secure my equipment gear and other screwing needs?

I'm looking at the 18v line.
 
#2 ·
Why do u need an impact driver at all? IMO they are no stronger then their chuck sporting counter parts. They have less options on the bits they except are mutch More expensive and are ridiculously loud. The only thing I do like about them is in tight spaces around finished work they don't have the chuck to rub on a freshly painted wall and leave the unmistakable black rub marks.
 
#3 ·
Electrical Student said:
Why do u need an impact driver at all? IMO they are no stronger then their chuck sporting counter parts. They have less options on the bits they except are mutch More expensive and are ridiculously loud. The only thing I do like about them is in tight spaces around finished work they don't have the chuck to rub on a freshly painted wall and leave the unmistakable black rub marks.
I use my 18v impact more than my 18v XRP hammerdrill. I bought it as an impulse bare tool and love it... Who cares about the noise. I have yet to strip a head and the compact size is nice. You'd have to pry it from my cold, dead hand to make me give it up
 
#4 ·
Electrical Student said:
Why do u need an impact driver at all? IMO they are no stronger then their chuck sporting counter parts. They have less options on the bits they except are mutch More expensive and are ridiculously loud. The only thing I do like about them is in tight spaces around finished work they don't have the chuck to rub on a freshly painted wall and leave the unmistakable black rub marks.
Smaller, faster, stronger. Seem to get the screw to go in far easier and tighter. I've used one a few times and loved it.
 
#5 ·
zwodubber said:
I use my 18v impact more than my 18v XRP hammerdrill. I bought it as an impulse bare tool and love it... Who cares about the noise. I have yet to strip a head and the compact size is nice. You'd have to pry it from my cold, dead hand to make me give it up
Do you know what the difference is between the versions they have. If someone could link to the best choice from dewalt that'd be nice :thumbsup:
 
#6 ·
I use the 1/4" 18V impact driver. It's for driving screws and fastening mostly. I helped a fried build his daughters playset and drove who knows how many 3 and 4 inch deck screws without the impact flinching, it's a beast. The impact wrenches are geared more toward automotive I believe.

I can get any bit I need for my impact, but I do always buy impact ready bits, extensions, nutsetters, etc...
 
#9 · (Edited)
Electrical Student said:
Why do u need an impact driver at all? IMO they are no stronger then their chuck sporting counter parts. They have less options on the bits they except are mutch More expensive and are ridiculously loud. The only thing I do like about them is in tight spaces around finished work they don't have the chuck to rub on a freshly painted wall and leave the unmistakable black rub marks.
First off, an impact driver will far outperform any drill of the same voltage as far as using on all different fasteners at the same time using much less battery. Drills are now strictly for drilling. Also, everybody does agree that they are lighter, and faster right?
 
#26 ·
#28 ·
At my last job I had the 12v DeWalt impact and the 1/2 drill. I kept a spade bit in the drill and used the impact for everything else. Pound for pound and like voltage the impacts cannot be beat. On my own work I use the Milwaukee 12v impact and the Makita 18v lion, the 12v doesn't drive 3/8" lags like the Makita can. I have a Hilti 14v drill for drilling holes. I am not a big DeWalt fan when I am paying for the tool myself.
 
#29 ·
MechanicalDVR said:
At my last job I had the 12v DeWalt impact and the 1/2 drill. I kept a spade bit in the drill and used the impact for everything else. Pound for pound and like voltage the impacts cannot be beat. On my own work I use the Milwaukee 12v impact and the Makita 18v lion, the 12v doesn't drive 3/8" lags like the Makita can. I have a Hilti 14v drill for drilling holes. I am not a big DeWalt fan when I am paying for the tool myself.
I got the DeWalt Referb for 179 it'll be here next Tuesday. Don't own any DeWalts so battery wasn't an issue.
 
#30 ·
Impact drivers take the impact off your wrist also. Imagine having to screw in lets say a 1000 deck screws with an impact driver held with one hand. Now imagine the same thing with a drill. Another example would be to try to unfasten an extremely tight nut with a drill held with one hand vs an impact driver held with one hand. These illustrations should point exactly why you use one vs the other, all else equal.
 
#31 ·
I bought one on eBay a few years ago, came with a fancy belt hook.
It's been thrown in mud, it's got PVC glue all over it, I use it until it's almost too hot to touch and it still goes like a madman.

I bought a 9 piece DeWalt 18V set on Boxing day (for you Americans, it's like black friday, but after christmas)
$400 off.
Came with a 1/2" drive impact, it's waaaay stronger than ANY air impact I've owned.
 
#35 ·
i know you like dewalt, but the makita impact is much better.

Everyone i see uses makita impacts.

you are really going to want the lithium ion as well.

Makita or Hilti are fantastic 1/4" impacts, all others are ok at best. I have the Makita 18v lion and drive 3/8" lags with it all the time.
 
#37 ·
I used the crap out of my Makita impact driver today and I used the same battery in my drill to drill some 3/4" holes, used the battery in my metal cutting saw to cut a few pieces of strut and a pile of EMT. I kept meaning to grab the other battery off the charger but never ended up doing it and rasn that one battery all day with no problem. Makita is definitely the way to go.
 
#45 ·
BigJohn20 said:
They're about to drop their new line of tools in retail channels (already available on Amazon), which is the 20v MAX system (actually an 18v system but they named it this because they didn't want to confuse current owners). From what I've read, their stuff is lighter, tougher, and more powerful than their current 18v offerings. It also uses a slide battery pack, so it is not compatible with the current 18v lines.
I just ordered the 5pc 20v max kit.

Hammer Drill
Sawzall
Impact
Flashlight
Skillsaw

Should have it next week, I'll post back and compare it to my current 18v kit.
 
#49 ·
Frasbee said:
I hate marketing ploys like that. Bosch did the same thing with their 10.8 volts. Because milwaukee was calling theirs 12 volt, Bosch got insecure and relabeled their baby line to 12 volt MAX. :rolleyes:
I hear ya but I can understand where they are coming from. They have the 18v max Nicads and also the 18v lithiums that are compatible with the 18v nicad tools. So calling the new set 18v lithium max would mean 3 different 18v lines and not all compatible.

Doesn't make it right to call it 20v when it's really 18 tho.