I work at an industrial facility with a lot of old equipment. I was always taught to meggar a motor to find out if it is bad. Is it best to meg between windings or meg to ground . thank you for your time
how to tell a motor is bad
DannyC327
21 - 40 of 40 Posts
Joined
·
21,736 Posts
Joined
·
584 Posts
For 3 phase motors, first bridge test it. This will make sure each phase winding is sound, and in tact.
It's been said already in this thread, but if you have an open phase winding, then your meggar test will not be accurate.
The bridge/resistance test will give you a good idea of the health of the phase windings. Should see consistent & balanced ohm readings across all 3 phases.
Only after you verify the windings are good, should you proceed to megger the motor.
Motor should also be checked for mechanical binding w/ bearings etc..if the motor passes bridge and megger tests.
It's been said already in this thread, but if you have an open phase winding, then your meggar test will not be accurate.
The bridge/resistance test will give you a good idea of the health of the phase windings. Should see consistent & balanced ohm readings across all 3 phases.
Only after you verify the windings are good, should you proceed to megger the motor.
Motor should also be checked for mechanical binding w/ bearings etc..if the motor passes bridge and megger tests.
Joined
·
17,035 Posts
Since it can be hard to do accurate winding resistance on motors, a good check is to do an impedance test with an AC supply.
If you can break the windings apart, ideally you do each winding separately, but in theory you could do phase-to-phase:
Put a variac on the windings and slowly ramp up to a stable voltage, staying below the nameplate FLA. Measure your current (for small motors you may have to use a series ammeter to get a value precise enough to be helpful). Compare measurements between each winding.
Serious turn-to-turn failures or problems with the backiron will show up as a current imbalance on that winding.
If you can break the windings apart, ideally you do each winding separately, but in theory you could do phase-to-phase:
Put a variac on the windings and slowly ramp up to a stable voltage, staying below the nameplate FLA. Measure your current (for small motors you may have to use a series ammeter to get a value precise enough to be helpful). Compare measurements between each winding.
Serious turn-to-turn failures or problems with the backiron will show up as a current imbalance on that winding.
Joined
·
321 Posts
Just to note... Motor windings don't always fail with a ground... I had one fail recently, it was a tube axial fan motor.
The drive showed a short circuit fault, measuring the resistance at the terminals showed the same between phases within an ohm or so (there was a slight imbalance, but I've seen far worse on functional motors).
The megger showed infinite at 1000v. Once we disassembled the ductwork, the paint was clearly discoloured from over heating, the motor cooling fan had melted onto the cowling.
Come to think of it, does anyone make a decent Lcr meter in a portable package?
The drive showed a short circuit fault, measuring the resistance at the terminals showed the same between phases within an ohm or so (there was a slight imbalance, but I've seen far worse on functional motors).
The megger showed infinite at 1000v. Once we disassembled the ductwork, the paint was clearly discoloured from over heating, the motor cooling fan had melted onto the cowling.
Come to think of it, does anyone make a decent Lcr meter in a portable package?
Joined
·
21,736 Posts
I once had an idea I never put to use or tried out.
What if you used a small DC power supply connected to the individual coils with your meter in series and reading amps.
Would this not be a way to check winding health? You could even use an AC supply and measure that current.
I'm talking very low voltage like in the range of 0-24 ac or dc volts.
But we would concern ourselves only with the current making sure we had the exact same voltage applied to each coil.
With a meter in series we can measure very low current. Milliamps and compare readings.
What if you used a small DC power supply connected to the individual coils with your meter in series and reading amps.
Would this not be a way to check winding health? You could even use an AC supply and measure that current.
I'm talking very low voltage like in the range of 0-24 ac or dc volts.
But we would concern ourselves only with the current making sure we had the exact same voltage applied to each coil.
With a meter in series we can measure very low current. Milliamps and compare readings.
I make all the electrons line up for their Flu shots
Joined
·
43,691 Posts
I do a quick markup and profit calculation at the red light intersections on my way over there before I ''find'' that the motor is bad............:thumbsup:
usually it is....................
usually it is....................
I hate to say it but if it doesn't measure a short to ground or open circuit with a regular meter, the chances a megger will find anything conclusive are slim. In my mind an impulse tester like a baker tester or sweep frequency analyzer is really the only thing that can conclusively tell you a motor is healthy. These sorts of tests are probably not worth doing on motors less than 50 or 100hp though.
Joined
·
1,483 Posts
That's been my experience. Some people here disagree with that though.
Sent from my C6725 using Tapatalk
Joined
·
21,736 Posts
But an ohm meter cannot read resistance on a bigger motor because the windings resistance is to low.
Putting a power supply on the winding should allow for precise current measurements. Not resistance. Current.
I do understand the meter does apply a voltage to measure the resistance. But the meter has limited power and limited current capabilities.
I have not tried doing this. Just something that I should have done to see if it would provide a better idea as to motor winding health.
Baker surge testers at one time were used exclusively by motor shops. It is how they determine motor winding health.
Today, some companies are actually investing in them for plant use and training employees to use them.
Joined
·
584 Posts
DLROs are what we use to perfrom what John Valdes is talking about I believe.
It injects current through the circuit, and based on the result, an ohm value is given.
We use DLROs quite often, ours can inject up to 10 amperes of current throught the circuit being tested.
It injects current through the circuit, and based on the result, an ohm value is given.
We use DLROs quite often, ours can inject up to 10 amperes of current throught the circuit being tested.
Joined
·
20,945 Posts
In this age where damn near everything installed new is on a VFD, the VFD is a fine troubleshooting tool in itself. If it says current limit, overload, ground fault, etc.... believe it. Pretty good chance (if it's not mechanically bound) it's the motor or the wire between the drive and the motor. Can't tell you how many "bad drives" I know people have replaced for these "faults", when the fault was actually diagnosing the motor. Nothing wrong with the drive.
While the tests can get exotic if you like, the old sniff test in the peckerhead will sort out the lion's share of suspect bad motors. No need to make it harder than it needs to be.
I've done a lot of work in food and pharma factories, where hundreds and hundreds of washdown rated motors are subjected to daily chemical and hot water washdown. EVERY motor and every local disconnect in such plants will meg "bad". By the way, "washdown rated" and "IP67" are pure marketing terms that means that it takes a little bit longer for water to get inside. :laughing:
While the tests can get exotic if you like, the old sniff test in the peckerhead will sort out the lion's share of suspect bad motors. No need to make it harder than it needs to be.
I've done a lot of work in food and pharma factories, where hundreds and hundreds of washdown rated motors are subjected to daily chemical and hot water washdown. EVERY motor and every local disconnect in such plants will meg "bad". By the way, "washdown rated" and "IP67" are pure marketing terms that means that it takes a little bit longer for water to get inside. :laughing:
Joined
·
21,736 Posts
And has weep holes that allow water to drain from the motor. We loved those facilities as a motor shop.
Make sure the correct plugs are removed depending on mounting position.
Marc I totally agree with you on drives being a very good piece of test equipment. However, a drive is smarter than most noses and will see the tiniest problem.
We got the occasional motor in shop faulting on winding failure/short. In several instances we could not find the problem and sent the motor back. Then they send it back with the same report.
Luckily in most of those cases the motors were still in warrantee and the manufacturer replaced them.
I would imagine many motors get rewound and even the shop cannot pin point (no pun intended) the exact cause.
Joined
·
11,602 Posts
Supro 500 baby....
Joined
·
1,483 Posts
Omfg, you people own stock in that company or something?
Sent from my C6725 using Tapatalk
Joined
·
6,069 Posts
Be careful that this is not taken out of context! :whistling2:
I think I posted this some time ago, but I have it on my "permanent record" with HR that I had been using "inappropriate terminology" when doing training classes on VFDs, because I called the motor termination box a "peckerhead". I was asked to provide proof in writing that the term came from some meaning other than what it appears to come from, and I could not find anything about the origin. HR on the other hand found something in writing that claimed it IS what it sounds like, and ordered me to change all of my presentations that used that term. I missed one and got written up after someone else used it.
I did, by the way, find evidence to what I was told in my youth was the origin: that it stemmed from "Picker Head", a protrusion on the drum of a cucumber picking rig that pulled the cukes off of the vine when the horse drawn tractor went over it. The way it came off of the drum looked a lot like a motor termination box, which came about a lot later, so the motor people referred to it as a Picker Head, and in the South, that became "pecker head", a term also used for dumb people, derived from the same source. But what I found was not definitive enough for the HR department here where I work now.
Joined
·
584 Posts
have that same kind of lawl laid down here also.
We can only say motor termination box now. sheesh. Folks that automatically think of the other term for peckerhead need to get their mind out of the gutter and leave us alone. ha
Joined
·
321 Posts
No one up here uses the term "pecker head", *except* in the offshore oil industry, and I assume that's because of mixing of professionals from the gulf if Mexico.
That being said... Was on a conference call a while back with a handful of electricians on a drilling rig on one end, and myself and several women from various office jobs on the other end....
The conference call was about developing a training package, and the term pecker head came up several times (in context, but it was a totally foreign word in that context to the women with me)
Eventually I had a chuckle, and said "I'm here with a group of non technical people, could you explain what a pecker head is?"
No one was offended, but up to that point there were few very embarrassed smiles.
That being said... Was on a conference call a while back with a handful of electricians on a drilling rig on one end, and myself and several women from various office jobs on the other end....
The conference call was about developing a training package, and the term pecker head came up several times (in context, but it was a totally foreign word in that context to the women with me)
Eventually I had a chuckle, and said "I'm here with a group of non technical people, could you explain what a pecker head is?"
No one was offended, but up to that point there were few very embarrassed smiles.
21 - 40 of 40 Posts
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
-
?
