Electrician Talk banner

Solve this service call......

14K views 93 replies 30 participants last post by  Rudeboy  
#1 ·
Today's service call:

HO removed a dwelling smoke detector because it was beeping. They replaced it with an identical unit, and it still kept beeping, so they just removed it and pulled the battery out.

I arrive and can't tell which smoke is the old one, and which one is the new one. So I put a known good battery in one, and install it.

It beeps every 10 seconds or so. OK, so I pull the battery out and install the second smokie. Again, it beeps every 10 seconds.

My volt pen says there's power.


What next?














(OK, for those of you who don't know how this works, I ALREADY KNOW THE SOLUTION. I am not asking for it, I am simply posting this thread for the benefit of those who wish to learn)
 
#6 ·
Today's service call:

HO removed a dwelling smoke detector because it was beeping. They replaced it with an identical unit, and it still kept beeping, so they just removed it and pulled the battery out.

I arrive and can't tell which smoke is the old one, and which one is the new one. So I put a known good battery in one, and install it.

It beeps every 10 seconds or so. OK, so I pull the battery out and install the second smokie. Again, it beeps every 10 seconds.

My volt pen says there's power.


What next?
At this point for me, the next step would be to give the Estwing treatment to both smokes. :whistling2:






Actually, I always make sure to use the test button. This often "resets" the smoke, and the chirping stops. Also, I try a fresh battery. As well as ensuring there is actually 120v, and the spices are secure.
 
#15 ·
When I arrived, I have provided with two identical smokes. One was original to the house wiring, and one that they purchased in hopes to solve the problem. The new one didn't solve the problem.

New battery installed in both, and they both beeped every 10 seconds or so.
 
#24 ·
how about another hint.

(sorry, it was a very long day and my brain doesn't really want to work overtime.)
My brain doesn't work undertime some days, either. :laughing:

Another hint:

When installed, neither smoke signalled the others when the test button was pressed.

What is on the circuit that is feeding the SD?
Beats the cheese out of me.
 
#30 ·
I have had some weird things happen with firex (don't know what brand you are working with). I know it sounds wierd but we actually had a service call where we changed another one out down the line and it actually made the other one stop chirping. Also if one is a co2 combo that would be where I would start. Smokes can be a pain to troubleshoot.
 
#47 ·
If I pushed the test button on the one I was replacing, it would sound, but none of the others.

I pushed a test button on the smoke in an adjacent room, and they all sounded except for the 'problem child'.

I never paid attention to the LED. Sorry.